Tag Archives: peer review

Authors January 22nd, 2015

Cooperation not confrontation- how to convince referees and respond to reviews

Some of the most difficult people to convince about new ideas, especially unusual or controversial ones, are experts. In other words, the reviewers who are likely to be peer-reviewing your paper are also those who are likely to be the most skeptical about it. Whether this is an advantage or disadvantage of the peer-review system…

read more comments

Authors January 8th, 2015

Helping Early Career Researchers to get peer review right

In 2013, more than 1.4 million scholarly articles were published in peer reviewed journals. As the rate of scholarly articles published each year increases, so does the pressure on peer review. In the 2009 Sense About Science peer review survey , 67% of respondents felt that formal training of reviewers would improve the quality of reviews. While…

read more comments

Societies Research Libraries January 7th, 2015

Recognition for peer review and editing in Australia – and beyond?

Following a lively discussion on the challenges of finding peer reviewers and journal editors at a Best Practice Journal Publishing seminar in our Melbourne office earlier this year a group of 40+ Australian Wiley editors recently wrote an open letter to their universities, funders, and other research institutions and organizations in Australia. Highlighting both the benefits…

read more 5 Comments

Societies Research Libraries November 7th, 2014

Mentoring the next generation of reviewers

Peer review is at the heart of scientific publishing. It provides the opportunity to discuss and improve upon a manuscript before publication and helps to ensure quality standards of articles published. But current complexities in the academic landscape, variations in the approach to assessing research, and difficulty securing reviewers due to demands on time are…

read more comments

Societies Research Libraries September 2nd, 2014

Simplification, education, transparency: ISMTE North American Conference 2014

“Even Einstein benefited from the peer review process,” said Adam Etkin, of PRE (Peer Review Evaluation) and Social Cite, while speaking at this year’s North American conference for the International Association of Managing and Technical Editors (ISMTE). During his presentation on the systems he has worked hard to develop—PRE-val/PRE-score and Social Cite—he shared an article…

read more 1 Comment

Societies Research Libraries August 20th, 2014

Advancing peer review: a Q&A with Adam Etkin of PRE

 We recently spoke with Adam Etkin,  Founder and Managing Director of PRE, a division of STRIATUS.  Adam is a veteran of the publishing industry and  formed PRE to assist members of the scholarly publishing community who are committed to preserving an ethical, rigorous peer review process. Q. Can you tell us about your background and your…

read more 1 Comment

Societies August 15th, 2014

5 key trends in professional publishing

One of the overriding themes of the ASAE conference in Nashville this year was the universal constant: change. From game-changing talks to hands-on learning labs, ideas and solutions abound on how to respond to a changing marketplace and membership base, but also how to proactively and positively implement your own changes. The Learning Lab session, “5…

read more comments

Societies Research Libraries July 23rd, 2014

5 things I learned about peer review at ESOF

There’s little doubt that peer review is an essential arbiter of scientific quality, so I think it’s important that we discuss its challenges and help answer the questions many researchers have surrounding it. That’s why I held two Sense About Science sessions on peer review at ESOF2014 – Europe’s top general science event – which…

read more comments

Authors June 12th, 2014

We’re experimenting in the Author Ecosystem. Want to help?

We are currently experimenting to develop new Author Guides that our authors will actually want to use, particularly new researchers looking to publish for the first or second time. We have been connecting with authors all over the world to inform progress by following the classic “T” approach to knowledge gathering: the broader, horizontal, climb-that-tree-and-look-around…

read more comments

Societies Research Libraries May 30th, 2014

#PeerReview-now trending on a newsfeed near you

It’s hard to match the buzzworthiness of peer review. Over the past several months alone, a number of conferences and workshops have tackled the topic, spawning lively debates in the Twittersphere and on blogs well after the events themselves concluded (overviews of Peer Review Watch’s Is Peer Review Broken? and BioMed Central’s Editors’ Conference are…

read more comments